When people think of BLACKPINK, they immediately picture top-tier visuals, chart-topping hits, and an undeniable stage presence. Yet, among this explosive group, Rosé stands out with a different vibe: a true artist, not just an idol.
But is that title justified? Is her solo career truly solid, or just a fleeting moment of glory? Most importantly, does she have what it takes to be one of K-pop’s top solo artists?
Let’s break it all down!
Rosé: A Vocal Powerhouse or Overhyped?
As BLACKPINK’s main vocalist, Rosé holds a crucial role in the group—but was it really earned, or was she just favored by YG?
🔥 A one-of-a-kind voice – Her husky, emotional tone is instantly recognizable, even among a sea of K-pop idols. That’s how she beat over 700 contestants to secure her spot at YG Entertainment in 2012.
🎸 More than just a singer – Rosé isn’t just about vocals; she shreds on the guitar like a pro. Whether it’s her acoustic version of “Gone” at THE SHOW, her sweet renditions on Sea of Hope, or the viral “Good Boys Gone Bad” cover (June 2024), she never fails to impress.
💃 Stage presence? Unmatched. – Rosé doesn’t need over-the-top choreography. Just her expressions and gestures alone can set the stage on fire.
But… is her vocal talent truly flawless? Or is it overrated?
The Vocal Controversy – “Rosé Needs Vocal Training”?!
Despite her massive fanbase, Rosé has often been caught in debates over her vocal technique. Some critics claim her voice lacks power, making her unfit to be a top-tier main vocalist.
🚨 Case in point? Her live performance of “Last Christmas” on Youtube BBC Radio 1 sparked an online debate, with comments like:
❌ “This is BLACKPINK’s main vocalist? Unbelievable!”
❌ “She seriously needs vocal training.”
❌ “We’ve reached an era where idols don’t even need to know how to sing?”
Sounds harsh, but does Rosé actually deserve the criticism? Or is she simply a victim of unrealistic expectations?
🔥 The truth: No, she might not have the powerhouse vocals of Taeyeon (SNSD) or Wendy (Red Velvet), but what makes her stand out is her unique vocal color. That signature tone—the kind that sticks in your mind from the very first note—is something not every singer can achieve.
And if her vocals were so weak, then why did Coachella go wild for her?
Going Solo: The Real Rosé Unleashed!
While Rosé shines in BLACKPINK, her solo career truly showcases her artistic depth.
🎵 “On The Ground” – No.1 on Billboard Global 200, highest-viewed K-pop solo MV in 24 hours (41.6M views). A deeply personal song about self-discovery.
🎵 “Gone” – A heart-wrenching ballad that left fans teary-eyed, especially during her performance at THE SHOW 2021.
🎵 “Final Love Song” – A powerful step forward, proving her vocal strength and artistic growth.
🎵 “APT” – A fresh experiment, blending a haunting melody with Rosé’s signature tone, showing she’s not just about sad ballads—she can own upbeat tracks too.
With every solo release, Rosé isn’t just an idol dropping music—she’s actively shaping her own artistic identity. At this point, there’s no doubt: she has both talent and substance!
Rosé vs. Jennie, Lisa, Jisoo – Who Dominates Solo?
Each BLACKPINK member’s solo career reflects their unique artistic identity.
🔥 Jennie – The “Luxury Queen,” exuding confidence and effortless class. Her debut solo track “SOLO” (2018) was an instant K-pop anthem.
⚡ Lisa – The “Hip-Hop Goddess,” serving unbeatable rap flows and heavy-hitting beats with “LALISA” and “MONEY”, both global smashes.
🌸 Rosé – The “Emotional Storyteller,” captivating fans with soulful, raw music rather than flashy performances.
🌺 Jisoo – The “Elegant Queen,” proving that deep, rich vocals can also be captivating, as seen in her solo debut “ME”.
So, in terms of viral impact? Jennie has the luxury image, Lisa dominates streaming numbers, but Rosé made history as the first BLACKPINK member to hit No.1 on Billboard Global 200. That’s an undeniable win.
Final Verdict: Rosé – Just an Idol, or a True Artist?
Jennie has the aura. Lisa has the moves. Jisoo has the elegance. But if we’re talking about the soul of BLACKPINK, that’s Rosé.
🔥 She’s not just an idol.
🔥 She doesn’t just sing—she breathes music.
🔥 And no matter how much controversy surrounds her, she stays true to herself.
So, in the end, does Rosé have what it takes to be recognized as a true artist?
You tell me!
